Dog chewing on a recycled rubber caterpillar dog toy

How to Pick the Right Toy for Your Dog

🐶 How to Pick the Right Toy for Your Dog

Choosing the right toy for your dog doesn’t have to be complicated—but it does take a little thought. The key is to match the toy to your dog’s size, age, chewing strength, and personality.

✅ Size Matters

Small dogs do best with lightweight toys they can carry and play with easily, while larger dogs need something more durable and appropriately sized to avoid choking hazards.

💪 Chewing Strength

Every dog is different when it comes to chew style:

Light chewers often enjoy soft, flexible rubber or plush toys.

Heavy chewers need tougher materials—durable rubber or reinforced fabric designed to stand up to serious gnawing.
Don’t underestimate soft rubber toys—some flexible designs can outlast even the hardest solid ones. Our own fur kids have proven that more than once!

🐾 Age-Appropriate Toys

Puppies need soft but durable toys, especially ones that soothe sore gums during teething.

Adult dogs are stronger and typically need tougher rubber or interactive toys that challenge them.

Senior dogs benefit from gentler toys that are easy on aging teeth and gums—similar to what you'd choose for a pup.

🎯 Match to Their Personality

High-energy dogs love games like fetch and tug-of-war.

Curious pups enjoy puzzles and enrichment toys that challenge their minds.

All dogs benefit from mental stimulation, so adding a few enrichment toys to your collection is always a win.

🧼 Safety First

Always choose toys made from non-toxic, dog-safe materials. While cheap supermarket toys might look like a bargain, they often wear out quickly—and may contain harmful chemicals. Investing in quality pays off with longer-lasting fun and safer play.


🧸 Final Tip

Dogs get bored—just like us! Keep things interesting by rotating their toys and introducing different types of play. Whether it’s a squeaky plush, a tough rubber ball, or a puzzle feeder, a variety of toys will keep your pup happy, healthy, and mentally engaged.

🛍️ Looking for tough, safe, and fun dog toys? Check out our collection—tested and approved by our own Boogs & Poods crew!

Back to blog